Carlo Rotella’s Good with Their Hands: Boxers, Bluesmen, and Other Characters from the Rust Belt by Lawrence Chua

Meet psych major and boxer Liz McGonigal, bluesman and entrepreneur Buddy Guy, and cops-turned-muses Eddie Egan and Sonny Grosso in Carlo Rotella’s anthology of blue-collar life stories Good with Their Hands.

Part of the Editor's Choice series.

BOMB 83 Spring 2003
BOMB 083
Carlo Rotella 01

Sonny Grosso and Eddie Egan in The French Connection, 1971. Courtesy of University of California Press.

Exactly where is the Rust Belt? Essayist and educator Carlo Rotella places it in the russet swath of America that extends across the old manufacturing capitals of the Midwest and Northeast. But this wide territory is also a state of mind. It is a place where America reckons with its own dramatic decay. Rotella sees something “poetic and heroic” happening in the shadows of crumbling mill towns and cold boxing gyms, and there is a romantic quality to the four stories he tells in this thought-provoking collection.

Perhaps romantic is not the right word. There is little that is dewy eyed in these stories of good hands, but there is much that is written of with great affection and love. The stories are at once a study of urban change, sporting life, and the general culture that surrounds manual labor. “Everything, at least in this book,” Rotella reveals, “proceeds from and returns to work.” The characters in this book have a sense of craft that tells us much about America’s unique toughness, always larger than life, as if it were a compensation for something softer and more generous at its core. Rotella introduces us to Liz McGonigal, a psychology major and female boxer who is hailed as a local hero in Erie, Pennsylvania, for upholding the city’s blue-collar reputation. In Chicago, bluesman and entrepreneur Buddy Guy survives the branding of the blues. In New York, old-school cops Eddie Egan and Sonny Grosso, who were the inspiration for William Friedkin’s 1971 film The French Connection, become Hollywood players themselves.

All these profiles are portraits of something larger than mere personality. They reflect important changes in American life: the impact of globalization, the transformation of inner cities into shopping malls and theme parks, the feminization of labor, the ever-smaller place of craftsmanship in culture, the relationship between images of crime and real crime, and the ways in which our ideas of the body, and the work done by it, are in flux. While one often wonders where Rotella is going, the writing is engaging and nearly always coheres in revelation. We learn, for example, that the gritty visual quality of The French Connection was achieved by underexposing and then force-developing the film, creating what its cinematographer described as “‘milk’ in the shadows.” Rotella’s analysis is far reaching, but sometimes seems strained. While he acknowledges that not every story in America is that of the immigrant’s ascent, it often seems like mere lip service as he goes on to impose that very narrative structure on the story of the American city. Still, there is much more to recommend this book. As all good stories should, the ones Rotella tells conjure a rich set of questions about the ways that life’s truths are handed down, whether it be in a flurry of dissonant notes or the arc of a well-crafted uppercut.


Good with Their Hands was released last fall by the University of California Press.

Francine Prose's My New American Life by Simon Van Booy
Francine Prose 01
Valeria Luiselli by Jennifer Kabat
Luiselli 1

Cities haunted by ghosts, ghosts that are a metaphor for language in their haunting doubling and mistranslations, language that’s full of holes, while the holes themselves are suggestive of abandoned places and writing that fails to describe anything accurately enough—this is Valeria Luiselli’s terrain.

Francine Prose’s My New American Life by Simon Van Booy
Francine Prose 01

Francine Prose’s novel, My New American Life, explores the story of Lula, an Albanian immigrant hired to nanny a motherless, morose teenage boy in the middle of the Bush/Cheney years.

John Phillip Santos’s The Farthest Home Is in an Empire of Fire: A Tejano Elegy by Callie Enlow
John Philip Santos 01

In John Phillp Santos’ tale of his families origins from Spain, he sets out on a quest to discover his heritage and explores the human fascination with borders.

Originally published in

BOMB 83, Spring 2003

Featuring interviews with Paul Pfeiffer, Pat Steir, Tom Sachs, Marie Ponsot, Steven Millhauser, Meshell Ndegeocelo, David Greenspan, and Neil Labute.

Read the issue
BOMB 083